Published February 1, 2025. Since publication (October 2026): in Bartz v. Anthropic the court held on June 23, 2025 that using the books to train Claude was a fair use, but not as to pirated library copies, and on July 20, 2026 it approved a $1.5 billion class settlement (the August 2026 notices of appeal concern only the attorney’s fee ruling); in Concord v. Anthropic the court denied Anthropic’s motion to dismiss the amended complaint on October 6, 2025; and Anthropic has since retired the Claude 3 models described below. Large language model (LLM) generative artificial intelligence (AI) systems are becoming more and more common in all aspects of life. These systems have the ability to respond to queries from users and generate responses. Who hasn’t had the experience of calling a customer service telephone line and being prompted by an automated system to answer a series of questions, in the hope of solving a problem without involving a living, breathing representative? Chat services on company websites, which are often the first line of communication between a company and the public, are increasingly powered by LLMs designed to mimic the conversation styles of real people.
Simply put, LLMs are here to stay, and we will all be exposed to AI-generated output more and more frequently in a number of areas.
As with any disruptive new technology, LLMs are creating economic winners and losers, which inevitably leads to litigation. Companies such as Meta and Microsoft are already being served with lawsuits claiming that their AI products and services are violating various rights of interested parties. Through a series of articles, the lawyers at IBL will discuss several of these cases, the claims being brought, the rights alleged to be violated, and the defenses being offered.
In the first of these articles, we will focus on two lawsuits being brought against Anthropic PBC.
1. Who is Anthropic PBC?
Anthropic PBC is a public benefit corporation founded in 2021 by former employees of OpenAI, including Daniela Amodei and Dario Amodei. Major investors in the company include Google and Amazon. In addition to publishing research on the interpretability of machine learning systems, Anthropic has developed several products.
One such product, Constitutional AI, is a set of techniques designed to align AI systems with human values, and to render AI systems harmless and honest. Anthropic has also developed a research method, Constitutional AI, which is a set of techniques designed to align AI systems with human values, and to render AI systems harmless and honest. Constitutional AI is designed to train an AI assistant to be harmless without human labels identifying harmful outputs, relying instead on a written list of principles. Anthropic has also released several versions of its flagship product, an AI driven generative LLM system known as Claude. Like all generative LLMs, Claude generates data outputs in response to queries from users.
It should be noted that Anthropic PBC is a public benefit corporation, or PBC, a legal form that is different from a certified “B Corp”. There is a significant difference between a PBC and a not-for-profit corporation, in that a PBC is expected to generate profits for its shareholders and investors. There is also a significant difference between a PBC and corporation, in that a PBC is expected to attempt to make a positive impact on society, while a corporation has no such obligation. Delaware recognizes public benefit corporations, and many other states, including Florida, recognize a similar form called a benefit corporation. Anthropic states that its public benefit purpose is the responsible development and maintenance of advanced AI for the long-term benefit of humanity.
2. How do LLM systems work?
The truth is, humans are still struggling to understand and explain exactly how computers sift through data, develop the ability to mimic human communication and generate other creative works when artificial intelligence techniques are used. People often refer to this process as “training” an AI system; really, this is a misnomer, since training implies the presence of a trainer. Simply put, AI system developers give LLMs access to huge pools of data, develop algorithms that govern how those LLMs sort through that data, and then refine the algorithms to narrow the parameters of acceptable responses generated by the LLM until the LLM is generating output that meets the needs of the developers. (Major commercial LLM systems do generally involve a lot of manual feedback and fine-tuning from large teams of human contributors – but arguably, this feedback is only secondary).
When a user inputs a query into an LLM, the LLM generates a response based on the statistical relationships it learned from its training data, in accordance with those governing algorithms. The larger the amount of data available to the LLM, the more comprehensive and accurate its responses are able to be.
Facing an AI or technology dispute?
Industria Business Lawyers advises on disputes and governance questions involving AI systems, software, and data. Describe your matter and we will contact you to schedule a consultation.
Request a Consultation or call (202) 860-1210
Related services: AI & Technology Disputes · IP Litigation · AI & Machine Learning Governance
Because of the way that they function, LLM systems make copies of the datasets that serve as the source of the responses the systems produce. Part of this is a function of how computers work, and there is legal precedent to support the proposition that this type of copying is legal. However, allegations have been made that there are times when the data included in the materials used to train LLMs, and which are available to LLMs in generating responses to queries, is protected by copyright. There are also allegations that, at times, the output generated by LLM systems includes copies of material protected by copyright, and often presents those copies as being created by the AI system itself as opposed to being created by the author of the underlying data.
3. What is Claude?
“Claude” is the trade name applied to a series of LLM AI products produced by Anthropic which can recognize text, computer code and images. Initially, Claude was available only to select users. However, with the release of Claude 2 in July of 2023, the AI system became available to the general public. Claude 3 followed in March 2024 in three versions: Opus, Sonnet and Haiku. These three versions of Claude 3 differ in their intended uses. Opus is designed for strong performance on highly complex tasks; Sonnet is intended for less complex tasks that can be completed more quickly; and Haiku is designed to mimic human conversation. Anthropic has since released newer Claude models and retired the Claude 3 family.
Anthropic promotes Claude as being able to create and draft books, plays, text messages, emails and virtually any form of written communication. Claude can also be used to generate custom tools that generate content in response to input from users. Anthropic makes Claude available on a monthly subscription basis; a limited version is also available for free.
Claude is at the center of the two lawsuits facing Anthropic. More specifically, at issue are the sets of data used to train the LLM and used by the LLM to generate responses to queries. In both cases, plaintiffs are alleging that data protected by copyright has been included in Claude’s dataset, in violation of the copyright holders’ rights. They are also alleging that the output generated by Claude violates their rights. In one case, the plaintiffs allege that Claude is actually competing with creators in the marketplace.
4. Concord Music Group, et al v. Anthropic PBC.
In the first lawsuit brought against Anthropic, several music publishers are alleging that Claude is violating the copyright in song lyrics those publishing companies own or control. The publishers claim that the copyright violations are widespread and systemic in the entire series of Claude LLM systems, both in the form of inputs into datasets being used in the training of the LLMs and in the output generated by the systems in response to queries from users. While other website and music lyric aggregators obtain licenses to access song lyrics, the music publishers suing Anthropic point out that Anthropic has not obtained any such licenses granting Anthropic the right to incorporate copyright protected lyrics into Claude datasets. The music publishers go on to allege that Claude sometimes generates infringing lyrics in response to queries that don’t actually request lyrics.
The lawsuit includes four specific claims. First, the music publishers allege that Anthropic is directly violating the copyrights in song lyrics by including protected song lyrics in the datasets for Claude. In essence, the music publishers are alleging the simple act of including the song lyrics in the datasets that power Claude is, in and of itself, a violation of copyright.
Second, the publishers allege both contributory and vicarious liability on the part of Anthropic, in that users of Claude are violating copyrights in song lyrics when they take the output generated by Claude and incorporate that output into their own works. In doing so, those users are not acknowledging the actual authorship of the work product they are presenting as their own.
Finally, the music publishers allege that Anthropic violates the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) by removing copyright management information, such as indicia of ownership, from song lyrics when compiling its datasets. The DMCA prohibits, among other things, intentionally removing or altering copyright management information, such as the author’s or owner’s name, knowing, or (in a civil case) having reasonable grounds to know, that this will induce, enable, facilitate or conceal an infringement (17 U.S.C. § 1202(b)).
The complaint includes several detailed comparisons of lyrics generated by Claude to copyright protected lyrics, pointing out the similarities. The music publishers go on to allege that Anthropic, allegedly worth some $5 billion, is profiting greatly off of its infringing activities.
There has been a fair amount of logistical wrangling in the case. Anthropic was successful in moving the case from Tennessee to California. Since publication (October 2026): the court dismissed the secondary-infringement and DMCA claims with leave to amend on March 26, 2025, and denied Anthropic’s motion to dismiss the amended complaint on October 6, 2025. In May 2026 the publishers dismissed their contributory and vicarious infringement claims with prejudice, and cross-motions for summary judgment were pending as of October 2026.
5. Bartz v. Anthropic PBC.
In another litigation, a group of journalists and authors have filed a proposed class action against Anthropic in the Federal court in the Northern District of California. Like the lawsuit brought by music publishers, the suit brought by writers alleges copyright infringement, and that Anthropic has made no effort to compensate writers for the inclusion of their works in the datasets used both to train Claude and appearing in the output generated by Claude.
However, unlike the suit brought by music publishers, the writers go on to allege that Anthropic is competing with the writers by generating content writers would otherwise be paid to create, thus diluting the market in which writers make their living. Since publication (October 2026): on June 23, 2025 the court held that Anthropic’s use of the books to train Claude was a fair use, but it refused to treat the pirated copies in Anthropic’s central library the same way and set those for trial. The case then settled, and on July 20, 2026 the court granted final approval of a $1.5 billion class settlement and dismissed the case. The writers also allege that Anthropic knowingly included pirated versions of their copyright protected works into the datasets for Claude. In another difference from the suit brought by music publishers, the proposed class action lawsuit brought against Anthropic by the writers includes a single cause of action – copyright infringement.
The case was later resolved by a $1.5 billion class settlement, which the court approved, entering judgment, on July 20, 2026.
6. What Is At Stake?
On one level, these cases are all about money, and a lot of it. Anthropic has received billions of dollars in investments. These cases primarily seek to force Anthropic to give creators their fair share of the revenues generated by the use of systems developed using their proprietary works.
On another level, these cases seek to put protections in place with respect to the way AI is used in the marketplace. To a great extent, then, these cases are about more than just the disappearance of customer service representatives and the decline of human interaction in the way we do business. Notably, neither of the cases suggests that LLMs should not exist. Rather, the cases seek to protect the work product of the people whose creations are powering AI systems, and to protect the marketplace for human creativity from competition presented by those systems. Our business litigation attorneys track these cases as they shape liability rules for AI developers and rightsholders.
7. How IBL can help you
Whether you are a creator looking to protect your work from being included in LLM datasets without your consent, or you are a company looking to incorporate generative LLM systems into your business while minimizing legal risks, our IP, AI, and privacy attorneys are here to help. For portfolio-level planning, start with our IP strategy consulting practice. Please reach out to schedule a consultation today.