Published March 21, 2025. Since publication: on March 27, 2025 the SEC filed a joint stipulation dismissing its case against Cumberland DRW LLC with prejudice, stating that the decision did not rest on any assessment of the merits. In March 2026 the SEC issued Release No. 33-11412, its interpretation of how the federal securities laws apply to crypto assets. See Digital Asset Custody & Broker-Dealer Compliance.
Written by: Aaron Krowne, Esq.
In the years before this article was written, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) cracked down on crypto market-makers for allegedly operating as unregistered broker-dealers, meaning firms that execute trades, facilitate transactions, or provide liquidity for others. Many assumed they were exempt from traditional broker-dealer rules due to regulatory uncertainty. However, as the market developed, the SEC became stricter with regard to parties handling such securities.
A long-standing legal requirement—that any firm dealing in securities as a main commercial business function register as a broker and/or a dealer—lays the foundation for these activities. Although this regulation is not new, it has not yet been clear how it applies to cryptocurrency trading companies. This shift raises critical questions—what activities put market-makers at risk, and how can they stay compliant?
Understanding SEC broker-dealer regulations
The SEC requires brokers or dealers (together, broker-dealers) to register under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, ensuring compliance with reporting, record-keeping, and investor protection rules. Under the Exchange Act, a broker is a person in the business of effecting securities transactions for others, and a dealer is a person in the business of buying and selling securities for its own account; trading for one’s own account, but not as part of a regular business, does not make a firm a dealer. This definition increasingly applies to crypto market-makers as digital assets and their trading venues face closer regulatory scrutiny.
While certain exemptions exist, they apply only to firms with limited roles in securities trading. For example, Rule 15a-6 exempts foreign broker-dealers from registration for certain limited activities, such as trades with U.S. investors they did not solicit, or dealings with U.S. institutional investors carried out through a U.S.-registered broker-dealer. Similarly, companies issuing their own securities may avoid broker-dealer status as long as they are not market-making or executing third-party trades.
Crypto market-makers, however, actively provide liquidity by buying and selling crypto assets, which can subject them to SEC broker-dealer rules when the assets they trade are securities. The agency has reinforced that firms engaged in trading activities involving securities—especially those earning transaction-based compensation—must register. As the SEC intensified its oversight, unregistered firms faced mounting legal and financial risks.
Why crypto market-makers face scrutiny
Although cryptocurrency market-makers and exchanges are essential for supplying liquidity, the SEC paid more attention to their business practices in the years before this article was written because of concerns about unregistered broker-dealer activity. Many have operated without registration, assuming regulatory uncertainty or jurisdictional separation would shield them from enforcement. Moreover, major operators in the US have argued that there is no clear pathway to registration, given that many (if not most) tokens likely do not qualify as securities, and it isn’t clear how the SEC’s broker-dealer regulations generally apply to blockchain digital assets and trading. Regardless of the reason for not affirmatively following the established regulatory pathway, the SEC saw this as a regulatory gap that could enable market manipulation and investor harm.
A key concern is wash trading, where firms artificially inflate trading volumes by executing buy and sell orders with themselves. This gives a misleading sense of market activity, deceives investors, and distorts price discovery.
Additionally, because market-makers and exchanges are central to trading activity, non-compliance with investor protection rules raises concerns about fairness and transparency in crypto markets generally. Without regulatory oversight, the SEC argued, such practices can go unchecked, increasing the risks of market manipulation and investor harm. However, industry advocates argue that other regulatory regimes (such as for the commodities sector), completely new ones tailored to crypto, or industry standards are a better way to remedy these issues than imposing traditional securities broker-dealer regulations.
Crypto market-making used to operate in regulatory uncertainty, and the SEC’s 2024 enforcement actions signaled a move toward stricter regulation.
Key enforcement actions and legal implications
SEC enforcement against Cumberland
Cumberland, a major crypto market-maker, was charged by the SEC in October 2024 with allegedly operating as an unregistered dealer, and the case was dismissed with prejudice in March 2025. According to the SEC, since at least March 2018 Cumberland acted as an unregistered dealer in over $2 billion of crypto assets that the SEC alleged were offered and sold as securities, buying and selling them for its own account as part of its regular business.
Cumberland has denied the allegations, saying that regulators would not let it use a registered broker-dealer it acquired in 2019 to deal in crypto assets other than bitcoin and ether (which, if true, elegantly illustrates the above-mentioned industry complaint that it is difficult or impractical to get covered under regulated status as a crypto market-maker). The SEC sought permanent injunctive relief, disgorgement of profits, and civil penalties.
At the time of writing (March 2025), there have been no reported court rulings or settlements in the lawsuit. Cumberland continued to operate while contesting the charges. Failing to register as a broker-dealer can lead to severe legal consequences. Had it been found liable, Cumberland could have faced:
- Hefty fines for non-compliance
- Operational restrictions impacting market-making activities
- Mandatory broker-dealer registration to continue trading securities
The case showed that even established firms could face SEC enforcement, prompting market-makers to review their compliance plans, particularly the risk of dealing in tokens the SEC considered securities, to avoid fines and business interruptions.
Fraud cases: The ZMQuant
The SEC’s crackdown extends beyond registration violations to fraud cases like ZM Quant Investment Ltd. (ZMQuant). In October 2024, the SEC charged ZMQuant and its employees, Baijun Ou and Ruiqi Lau, with manipulating the markets for crypto assets, creating the false appearance of an active trading market to induce investors to buy the crypto assets.
ZMQuant’s infractions included deceptive statements and manipulative tactics, in contrast to Cumberland’s case, which concentrated on registration errors. This distinction is important because the government may fine some companies for not registering as broker-dealers, but those engaging in fraud may face more severe punishments, such as criminal prosecution, civil penalties, and permanent trading bans.
This case highlights the broader risks for cryptocurrency companies. In addition to inviting regulatory enforcement, manipulative trading activities undermine investor confidence and cause market instability. The SEC’s assertive approach at the time indicated that enforcement actions would target companies involved in deceptive practices and compliance violations.
What should crypto firms do to stay compliant?
When this article was written in March 2025, the SEC was pursuing crypto market-makers; days later it dismissed the Cumberland case, saying the dismissal would help it reform and renew its regulatory approach to the crypto industry. For those who assume that the new “crypto-friendly” administration in 2025 will give crypto exchanges and market-makers a free pass, we would direct them to the SEC’s press release announcing the Cyber and Emerging Technologies Unit, which it states will actively pursue fraud. Thus, crypto market-making enterprises need to ensure they are insulated from fraudulent and manipulative conduct, and adhere to any applicable securities regulations to avoid serious legal consequences proactively.
- Broker-dealer registration: Firms that act as brokers or dealers in tokens that are securities generally must register with the SEC as broker-dealers unless an exemption applies, and failing to do so can lead to fines, trading bans, or forced shutdowns.
- Strong compliance programs: If required to register, simply registering isn’t enough. Covered firms must have proper controls to prevent illegal trading, maintain accurate records, and conduct regular audits to ensure they follow securities laws. Even firms that may not be required to register should have similar controls and robustness of compliance to a registered firm, to avoid becoming ensnared in legal problems.
- Professional legal advice: Cryptocurrency regulations are complex and changing continuously. Misinterpretation of the law can result in harsh fines. Firms should work with counsel who focus on securities and broker-dealer compliance.
- Continuous evaluations and revisions: Compliance is a continuous process. Businesses should periodically examine their policies, monitor changes to the regulations and enforcement environment, and modify their operations as necessary.
As oversight continues to change, legal guidance can help firms keep their compliance programs current. Arrange a consultation today to learn how we might assist you in safeguarding your enterprise and keeping ahead of regulatory risks.