Published October 13, 2024. The law has changed since: SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 122, effective January 30, 2025, rescinded the SAB 121 guidance discussed below. See Digital Asset Custody & Broker-Dealer Compliance.
Written by: Aaron Krowne
Introduction
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has long been a central figure in regulating financial markets in the USA. However, its stance on cryptocurrency has often drawn criticism from industry players. One such instance is the issuance of Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 121 (SAB 121) in March 2022, a controversial guidance that fundamentally altered how SEC-regulated companies holding crypto assets on behalf of customers should account for them. Recently, however, the SEC seems to be reconsidering its stance, suggesting a potential shift in its regulatory approach. In this article, we will examine what SAB 121 originally entailed, who it impacted, situations where it doesn’t apply, the softening of the SEC’s stance, and how entities can navigate this changing regulatory landscape.
Key Takeaways
- SAB 121 Overview: Issued by SEC staff in 2022, SAB 121 required companies holding cryptocurrency for customers to recognize both an asset and a corresponding liability on their balance sheets, accounting for the fair market value of the crypto-assets.
- Who It Affects: The guidance primarily affected centralized exchanges, brokers, custodians, and other financial institutions that safeguard crypto-assets on behalf of customers. All of these entities had to be SEC-regulated for the guidance to apply (however, conceivably, the SEC could have taken the view that an entity that should have been regulated by the SEC with respect to certain acts fell under the guidance).
- Exceptions to SAB 121: Until SAB 121 was rescinded, SEC staff did not object in specific cases when certain entities, such as introducing broker-dealers and bank holding companies, did not recognize a safeguarding liability because they met specific regulatory criteria and obtained relevant legal opinions.
- Evolving SEC Stance: In 2024 SEC staff accepted, case by case, that certain custody arrangements fell outside SAB 121, and SAB 122 then rescinded SAB 121 entirely, effective January 30, 2025.
- Legal Guidance Is Critical: Obtaining external legal advice could be instrumental for institutions seeking to characterize liability under SAB 121. This advice (which could include formal legal opinions) could provide legal assurances that assets were sufficiently safeguarded, SAB 121 notwithstanding, and limit associated regulatory burdens.
What Is SAB 121?
The SAB 121 was issued by the SEC to clarify accounting standards for SEC-regulated companies that are involved in safeguarding crypto-assets on behalf of their customers. The guidance required these entities to recognize both an asset and a corresponding liability on their balance sheets, reflecting the obligation to safeguard the assets, which had to be accounted for at fair market value (FMV).
This accounting treatment differs from traditional financial instruments, sparking outrage in the crypto industry when it was introduced. Unlike banks or other financial institutions, SEC-regulated crypto-asset custodians and brokers were arguably compelled to account for customer custodial assets as liabilities, introducing additional complexities and risks in financial reporting.
For example, under the guidance, if the company held $1 million worth of Bitcoin for its customers, it had to list $1 million as an asset and $1 million as a liability. If the value of the Bitcoin changed, say dropping to $900,000, both the asset and the liability needed to be adjusted. This is far stricter than the comparable reserving rules for, e.g., banks.
Who Does SAB 121 Apply To?
SAB 121 applied to entities that file reports under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Exchange Act) and those that have submitted or filed a registration statement under the Securities Act of 1933 or the Exchange Act. This included companies that have filed for public offerings or have ongoing reporting obligations with the SEC. Additionally, it covered entities that file offering statements or amendments under Regulation A, a framework for small and medium-sized companies to raise capital through public offerings, as well as those subject to ongoing periodic and current reporting requirements of Regulation A.
SAB 121 also extended to private companies involved in mergers or acquisitions with shell companies, including Special Purpose Acquisition Companies (SPACs), where their financial statements are included in SEC filings. These entities, if they held crypto-assets for customers (such as centralized exchanges or banks), had to report those assets as liabilities on their balance sheets until SAB 122 rescinded SAB 121 effective January 30, 2025. They were also required to disclose the nature and amount of crypto-assets held, providing a clear breakdown of each significant asset and any risks tied to concentration in crypto-related activities.
SAB 121 primarily affected entities like centralized cryptocurrency exchanges, custodians, or banks that hold crypto-assets on behalf of their customers.
Industry Backlash to SAB 121
The industry, including the entities and regulators, criticized the SEC for SAB 121 for a number of reasons, including:
- Increased Capital Reserve Requirements: Entities, particularly banks, argued that reporting custodied crypto assets as liabilities could trigger increased capital reserve requirements under regulations that the SEC does not administer. This would force firms to hold more capital, limiting their ability to engage in income-producing activities like lending. As a result, offering crypto custody services could become economically infeasible.
- Impact on Crypto Custody Services: SAB 121 might disproportionately affect banks and other financial institutions with experience in offering custody services, potentially forcing them to abandon crypto custody plans. This would limit options for consumers seeking safe custody of their crypto assets and prevent some of the most experienced institutions from providing these services.
- Risk of Crypto Assets Being Exposed in Bankruptcy: The on-balance sheet treatment of crypto assets could expose customers to creditor claims if a custodian firm goes bankrupt. In contrast, off-balance sheet treatment, typically used for other assets, ensures that customer assets remain safe from creditors.
- Economic Infeasibility: By imposing additional liabilities on entities holding crypto assets, SAB 121 could make crypto custody services financially unsustainable for banks and other institutions, ultimately harming consumers by reducing their options.
GAO and Congressional Objections to SAB 121
Following significant backlash from the industry, the Government Accountability Office (GAO), responding to a request from Senator Cynthia Lummis, concluded in an October 31, 2023 decision that SAB 121 was a rule under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) and thus should have been submitted to Congress under the Congressional Review Act (CRA). The CRA, enacted in 1996, requires all federal agencies to submit a report on each new rule to Congress and the Comptroller General before it can take effect. The CRA allows Congress to review and potentially disapprove agency rules within 60 days using special legislative procedures. Under the APA, a rule is broadly defined as an agency statement designed to implement or interpret law or policy with future effect. GAO argued that SAB 121 met the definition of a rule under the APA and was not exempt from CRA’s reporting requirements.
Following GAO’s decision, Congress acted through H.J. Res.109, a bipartisan resolution to disapprove SAB 121 under the CRA. The resolution passed both the House and the Senate, marking the first crypto-specific legislation to achieve such progress in Congress. However, President Biden vetoed the resolution, stating that the “resolution would inappropriately constrain the SEC’s ability to set forth appropriate guardrails and address future issues.” SAB 121 stayed in effect at the time because the House did not reach the two-thirds majority needed to override the veto, but SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 122 rescinded it effective January 30, 2025.
When SAB 121 Doesn’t Apply
Nevertheless, the SEC seemed to recognize the backlash against SAB 121 as strictly-written, and has apparently softened its stance since. For instance, as outlined in a September 2024 speech by Paul Munter, the SEC’s Chief Accountant, at the 2024 AICPA & CIMA Conference on Banks & Savings Institutions, SEC staff did not object in certain situations to a conclusion that an arrangement was outside the scope of SAB 121. While SAB 121 generally required entities to recognize a liability for safeguarding crypto-assets held for others, SEC staff did not object in specific cases where entities met particular criteria. Here are some detailed examples:
Bank Holding Companies Safeguarding Crypto-Assets
In one example, a bank holding company safeguarding crypto-assets for institutional clients was not required to recognize a liability under SAB 121. The SEC staff did not object, based on the following criteria:
- Regulatory Approval: The bank obtained written approval from its state prudential regulator for its proposed crypto-asset safeguarding activities and engaged with its primary federal prudential regulator.
- Operational Controls: Comprehensive controls were in place to mitigate risks associated with holding cryptographic private keys for institutional customers.
- Bankruptcy-Remote Structure: The crypto-assets were held in bankruptcy-remote wallets, meaning they were legally protected from being included in the bank’s estate in the event of insolvency.
- Limited Custodial Role: The bank’s activities were limited to safeguarding and transferring crypto-assets based on customer instructions, without any rehypothecation or use of those assets by the bank.
- Legal Opinion: A legal opinion from an outside counsel supported the conclusion that the crypto-assets would not be part of the bank’s receivership estate in case of insolvency.
Introducing Broker-Dealers
In another scenario, SEC staff said it would not object to a conclusion that a registered introducing broker-dealer facilitating crypto transactions for customers did not need to recognize a liability under SAB 121, where the following conditions were met:
- No Control of Cryptographic Keys: The broker-dealer, or its agents, had no possession or control of the private keys required to transfer the crypto-assets.
- Third-Party Custody: The crypto-assets were held by a third party acting as the customer’s agent, not the broker-dealer’s.
- Clear Disclosures: The broker-dealer clearly communicated to customers that safeguarding services were provided by the third party, and not by the broker-dealer itself.
- Direct Customer-Third Party Relationship: Customers had a direct contractual relationship with the third party for safeguarding, and could interact with the third party independently of the broker-dealer.
- Legal Opinion: A legal opinion from an outside counsel confirmed that the third party acted as an agent of the customer, and the broker-dealer had no legal obligation to compensate for any losses from the third party’s handling of crypto-assets.
In both of these examples, the SEC staff’s decision not to object was based on specific facts, legal opinions, and representations provided by the entities involved. These criteria reflected how SEC staff applied a more flexible approach to SAB 121, depending on the particular risk mitigation and legal structures in place.
Further Walk-Back
The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation (BNY Mellon) has received a “no-objection” from the SEC to safeguard digital assets like bitcoin and ether without classifying them as balance-sheet liabilities. This approval depends on BNY Mellon’s use of individual crypto wallets, ensuring that customer assets are protected and kept separate from the bank’s assets in the event of insolvency. The move also signals a softening of the SEC’s initial stance under SAB 121.
SEC Chair Gary Gensler noted in an interview that while the consultation was focused on two specific crypto assets, the custody model could apply to a wide range of digital assets. He emphasized that the SEC’s decision relates to the custody structure rather than the nature of the assets, potentially allowing other banks to adopt similar crypto custody models and broaden their digital asset offerings.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the SEC staff’s 2024 actions reflected a notable shift from its initial hardline approach under SAB 121, responding to industry concerns over the burdensome accounting treatment of crypto-assets. By not objecting in specific cases and allowing for more flexible interpretations, particularly for institutions like introducing broker-dealers and banks with robust safeguards, SEC staff demonstrated a willingness to adapt its guidance to the unique challenges of the crypto space. This evolving stance signals that the regulatory landscape for digital assets may continue to soften as both the industry and regulators strive to find a balanced approach.
At Industria Business Lawyers PLLC (IBL), we help broker-dealers and other financial institutions navigate SEC accounting and custody guidance for crypto-assets. Our legal team can advise on legal opinions and on compliance, with the aim of reducing risk exposure. Reach out to us today for guidance on how to protect your business and clients in an evolving regulatory landscape.
FAQs
What is SAB 121?
SAB 121 was SEC staff guidance issued in March 2022 that required entities holding crypto-assets for customers to recognize both a liability and a corresponding asset on their balance sheets, until SAB 122 rescinded it effective January 30, 2025. This is meant to reflect the obligation to safeguard crypto-assets.
Who is affected by SAB 121?
SAB 121 primarily affected institutions involved in safeguarding crypto-assets, such as crypto exchanges, custodians, and broker-dealers, particularly those acting on behalf of customers.
Why has SAB 121 caused controversy?
SAB 121 sparked backlash because it required companies to list customer crypto-assets as liabilities, which could lead to increased capital requirements and make crypto custody services more expensive or economically unfeasible. Some argue that it exposes customer assets to additional risks, such as being claimed by creditors if a company goes bankrupt.
How has the SEC responded to industry concerns about SAB 121?
In response to industry concerns, SEC staff first accepted, in certain cases, that arrangements fell outside SAB 121, and then rescinded SAB 121 entirely through Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 122, effective January 30, 2025. Before the rescission, for example, SEC staff did not object where some banks and broker-dealers concluded that they did not have to list crypto-assets as liabilities under specific conditions, such as holding assets in bankruptcy-remote structures or using third-party custodians. For example, before the rescission, staff did not object when some banks and broker-dealers concluded that they did not have to list crypto-assets as liabilities under specific conditions, such as holding assets in bankruptcy-remote structures or using third-party custodians.
Why are legal opinions important under SAB 121?
Legal opinions were crucial because they provided clarity on legal protections for crypto-assets. For instance, they could support a conclusion that customer crypto-assets were protected in case of the company’s bankruptcy or that broker-dealers were not responsible for third-party custodianship. These legal opinions helped companies address SEC staff expectations under SAB 121 and reduce risks.
[1] SEC, Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 121, accessible at [Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 121 (SAB 121)]
[2] GAO, Securities and Exchange Commission—Applicability of the Congressional Review Act to Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 121, Oct 31, 2023, accessible at [Government Accountability Office (GAO) decision]
[3] Congress, H.J.Res.109 – Providing for congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, US Code, of the rule submitted by the SEC relating to “Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 121”, accessible at [House Joint Resolution 109]
[4] The White House, A Message to the House of Representatives on the President’s Veto of H.J.Res. 109, accessible at https://bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov/briefing-room/presidential-actions/2024/05/31/a-message-to-the-house-of-representatives-on-the-presidents-veto-of-h-j-res-109/
[5]SEC, Speech by Paul Munter, Chief Accountant, Remarks before the 2024 AICPA & CIMA Conference on Banks & Savings Institutions: Accounting for Crypto-Asset Safeguarding Obligations—A Facts-Based Analysis, accessible at [Chief Accountant Paul Munter’s statement]
[6] Bloomberg, BNY Approved by SEC for Crypto Custody Beyond ETFs, Gensler Says, accessible at [Bloomberg coverage on BNY’s SEC approval]